Spelling games: an awkward example

English spelling is probably the worst nightmare of anyone involved in adult literacy – teachers and learners. The biggest challenge for any learner is to find out how they can learn: which strategies might work for each individual. i like spelling games, but i’ve yet to find the perfect example.

Recently Larry Ferlazzo reviewed a small program, “Take on the Teacher” ..it’s an interesting idea, with mixed results:

  • => This one has a highly visual interface which is potentially engaging,
  • => however it’s a strange characterisation of the teacher at the board (why pretend the visitor is challenging a teacher, when we are clearly taking on a computer program?)
  • => and you’re right.. spelling programs need both audio and context (either visual or the classic “in a sentence”). Without context, words can have multiple meanings.. or be meaningless.

take on the teacher spelling game

i was caught out on the word “baul”. i managed to select this word correctly as the incorrectly-spelled word.. but i was unsure if they wanted me to write “ball” or “bawl” as the correct version. Given that “tantrum” was in the list, i chose “bawl” (to cry loudly).

Wrong! Says the “teacher”. Surely a teacher would have more insight and flexibility than this machine script.

Dear reader, do you have any favourite screen-based spelling games? Applications that are less faulty than “take on the teacher”?

thanks and kind regards, michael

Links:

Related posts:

  1. games for learning change .. ethical? Recently, David was looking for networked games, to reward the...
  2. Play the Game This year (’05) at PRACE, we were very fortunate to...
  3. How hard is it to set Language (Australian!) ? Whenever i glance over the shoulders of anyone on a...
  4. New Game: “Keyboard Crazy” Here’s an example of the world of technology emerging into...
  5. image labelling game An interesting idea from Google: they want to improve the...

November 5th, 2009 in adult literacy, e-learning | tags: , , ,

Comments (2)

Wendell DrydenNovember 6th, 2009 at 01:36

Sometimes we use games like Text-Twist (variants on Yahoo Games and Facebook) or Bookworm (ditto). There’s the same frustration of working with a machine, of course, and I’m suspicious of some of the words.

My personal favourite is an old version of Larry Parker’s Hangman 1.0 that used to be freeware and/or $15 US shareware. It’s an old dos desktop game from the late ’80s (I think) for VGA. But it has six word lists to choose from, all of which can be edited – by learners, quite easily – to create individualized spelling lists. (Putting it on multiple classroom desktops yields even more lists.) The hint function – which can also be edited – avoids the difficulty of words-without-context.

There are many other versions of hangman out there, but I’ve never seen one that was as flexible. Sadly, like many great DOS driven learning or text-based games – remember interactive fiction!?! – it seems impossible to find on the web nowadays.

;)

Alexandra GibsonMay 13th, 2010 at 02:38

Text Twist is an exciting game and it is also educational. this game can also help in spelling and vocabulary.;,~

Leave a comment

Your comment